Email marketing · Client case study

Email Marketing Is Dead?

A client’s open rate fell to 5%. Here’s what we changed to bring it back to 44% in six months.

Email Marketing Is Dead? cover with a glossy envelope, a purple inbox tray and a check mark.

A new client came to us with about 45,000 contacts and a reported email open rate of 5%. It used to be 58%. The client had worked with several agencies that promised to handle email marketing. By the time we sat down with the owner, messages were landing in spam and the business had already switched providers more than once.

We spent the next six months cleaning up the list, fixing the sending setup and giving customers a reason to read the emails again.

How did a 45,000-contact list get to 5% opens?

The old setup sent the same email to the full list every day. Inactive addresses stayed in the rotation. The agencies had collected addresses through several channels without confirming them, and part of the list had been bought in bulk. That put people who’d never asked to hear from the business on its daily mailing list.

The emails read like someone had asked AI to write an email just to have something to send. The subject lines were generic, the same offers went to everybody and there was little in the message that sounded like the business. If someone wanted out, unsubscribing felt like an interview.

The explanation the client kept hearing was that the provider was the problem. After several switches, DKIM and DMARC were still set up incorrectly. Promotions, invoices and account updates also came from one address. The business had spent years building its name around that domain, so we worked on recovering its reputation.

What did we change first?

Take about 18,000 contacts out of the mailing rotation

We reviewed which addresses were receiving or opening the emails. About 27,000 contacts had at least one recorded open and made up the list we kept for the recovery. We removed the rest from marketing sends. For new subscribers, we put address confirmation in place so the business could see who had signed up.

Send smaller batches on a schedule

We capped this client’s recovery sends at 5,000 messages per day and spread those sends over roughly 12 hours, when customers were more likely to be awake. For the first three months, we rotated groups so each person received no more than one marketing email a week. We followed the sending domain’s reputation in Google Postmaster Tools as the schedule settled. Gmail recommends starting with engaged recipients, sending at a consistent rate and increasing volume gradually. Gmail’s sender guidelines

Make unsubscribing simple

We replaced the questionnaire with a visible link and a single confirmation. If someone wants to leave, let them go. Gmail also requires bulk senders to support one-click unsubscribe through email headers on promotional messages. Gmail’s unsubscribe requirements

How did we fix the sending setup?

We checked SPF, DKIM and DMARC with MXToolbox. SPF identifies authorized senders. DKIM signs the message. DMARC checks that an authenticated domain aligns with the domain recipients see in the From address. Those checks matter every time a provider is changed. MXToolbox’s authentication tools · Gmail’s authentication guidance

We organized outgoing mail by purpose. Promotions went through marketing@, billing through invoice@, alerts through notification@, and automated messages that didn’t need replies through noreply@. Each type of email had a clear job. Gmail assesses volume from the same primary domain together, which makes the list and sending habits important across addresses. Gmail’s guidance on sending domains

We used Resend for this client and use other providers for other clients. Pick one that fits the budget and the way you send. The setup and day-to-day habits still need someone to own them.

Would you read the email you’re about to send?

We changed the subject lines and sent offers based on what different customers cared about. Some were interested in one product and paid little attention to the others. Over six months we learned enough about those interests to write different emails for different groups.

We still use AI to help draft and lay out emails. Someone has to read the output, though. Would a person actually say this? Does the subject line tell me what I’m getting? Is there a reason this particular customer should open it? If the only reason to send the email is that it’s Tuesday, we have more work to do.

What happened after six months?

Reported open rate
5% → 44%
List after cleanup and confirmed signups
27,000 → 34,000

The domain’s reputation had largely recovered by the six-month mark. The list grew by about 7,000 confirmed addresses, and that new group was opening at around 60%. The 44% was the reported result across the broader list, which included people who had been on it longer.

We used campaign reports to track opens and Postmaster Tools to monitor reputation and delivery signals. An open rate measures recorded opens. It can’t tell you where every unopened message went. Gmail’s guidance on open rates and Postmaster Tools

Source: AMÁRQUEZ’s six-month account of the client work. The client and previous agencies are unnamed.

What should an email agency be able to show you?

Ask to see a campaign they’ve run over time or a deliverability problem they’ve fixed. Where did the addresses come from? How did they decide who got each email? What would make them slow down sending? Ask them to show how they check authentication, handle unsubscribes and read a deliverability report. If an agency tells you, “We use AI to set all of that up. AI knows how to do it,” that’s the real red flag. You want someone who can explain why a message should go to a particular group and who will read it before it goes out.

Email deliverability FAQ

Can switching providers fix email going to spam?

Switching can help if the old infrastructure is part of the problem. Start by checking authentication, recipient complaints, volume changes and the quality of the list. Those checks tell you what needs to change with the move. Gmail’s troubleshooting guidance

Should every business use the same 5,000-email limit?

We chose that ceiling for this list and recovery plan. Set your schedule around your own sending history, audience and delivery feedback. Gmail’s bulk-sender threshold is a separate rule based on messages to personal Gmail accounts. Gmail’s bulk-sender FAQ

What should you bring to an email deliverability review?

Bring the sending domain, provider, approximate list size and recent campaign reports. Tell us where addresses came from, how often you send and when the problems started. A sample email also helps us see what your customers see.

Need help getting your email marketing back on track?

Tell us what you send, how often you send it and what changed. AMÁRQUEZ can help clean up your list, fix your sending setup and run campaigns around what customers actually want to read.

Talk to us about email marketing

Read next · How to choose a marketing agency